The number one mistake sellers make in 2026 is the same one they've been making since the market normalized: overpricing. Here's what strategic pricing actually looks like.
The number one mistake sellers make in 2026 is the same one they've been making since the market normalized: overpricing.
I understand why it happens. You've seen what a neighbor's home sold for at the peak. You've got Zillow's Zestimate on your phone. And you love your house — it's your home, and it has value that a number doesn't capture.
But here's the reality of today's market.
Buyers are sophisticated and patient
Buyers in 2026 have access to the same data you do. They see what comparable homes sold for. They see how long your listing has been sitting. And they draw conclusions. A home that's been on the market for 60+ days — even if it was originally overpriced — develops a stigma. Buyers wonder what's wrong with it.
The math of overpricing
An overpriced listing eventually sells at a discount anyway. But by then, you've lost weeks of peak market exposure, your best qualified buyers have moved on, and you've potentially left money on the table compared to what a strategic launch would have gotten you.
What strategic pricing looks like
I do a thorough comparative market analysis (CMA) before we set a price. We look at recent sales of genuinely comparable homes — not different neighborhoods or different conditions. We look at what's active and what's pending. We factor in seasonal demand and your personal timeline.
The goal isn't to underprice. It's to attract multiple interested buyers, which creates competition and often produces a price at or above market. That's what happens when a well-prepared home hits the market at the right price.
What I tell my sellers
Your first 30 days on the market are your most valuable asset. Protect them by pricing right. Don't give them away by testing the market at a number that won't stick.
Ready for a market analysis? I'll give you an honest number, not the one that just makes you feel good.

Elena Mitchell
Realtor® · Coldwell Banker Realty · Sarasota, FL
Have questions? Elena is always happy to chat.
Contact Elena →